Nylig aktivitet

3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Primary Bath Remodel
    7 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Linea

Thanks for clarifying that the tub and shower share a wet room. Before settling the layout, I’d put the room’s dimensions, door travel, windows, fixtures, and drains on one measured plan, then check how the glass door works with access to the tub and whether any new wall makes cleaning more difficult. Show the waterproofing and drainage approach for the whole wet area before finishes are chosen. If you’re moving the toilet, have the plumber confirm the drain route before the plan is fixed. Could you share the room dimensions and explain what you hope to improve by moving the toilet?

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

I don't see any statement about one drawing being existing. The drawings are exactly the same (except rotated toilet room) with notes about proposed work, so it appears they are just different versions of a proposed remodel.

An existing conditions showing windows, doors, existing plumbing, and adjacent rooms, is what is required for useful advice you can only get from non-AI contributors.

1 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Small bedroom layouts help
    14 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

This should be tagged as a "furniture" thread.

A habitable room must be minimum 70sf, which the little room doesn't meet, so there is that.

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
Rich P

If we go the bunk bed route, we're looking at the type with stairs. Those seem to be about 100" long. That would take up most of the west wall.

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Best Gable Style for a Future Attic Conversion
    11 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

The house as shown will not allow a 3rd floor under the roof. The main gable is not steep enough.

There are some issues with the rendering, and that may be misleading you. The middle windows are shown without a header supporting the roof. The window over garage is too high. The main gable shows that the main house is only slightly deeper than the front gable is wide (even if a lower slope than the front gables, it would lower ceiling height even more).

But, in general, to answer your question, a shed roof dormer maximizes available room under a 1/2 story roof.

1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
None

A Barnyard Tudor. very interesting

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
BeverlyFLADeziner

Long before that roof style was used for barns it was Dutch Colonial.

2 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kan lide en kommentar i en diskussion: Installing lights and wood plank ceiling
    19 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
chispa

Electrical wiring and recessed LED lights housing gets done first.

Planks get installed/cut around the lights and then the trim and/or LED light module for the recessed lights get installed.

You need to order recessed lights that are designed for sloped/angled ceiling or the light beam will shine sideways and not downwards.

Get recessed lights where the light source is "recessed" into the can.

Do Not get the cheaper wafer lights! They don't look as good and will give you glare.

5 synes godt om Gem     Takket af porkchop_z5b_MI
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Looking for Feedback on Plans Created by our Designer
    4 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

Bedroom 1 is larger than the Master in Option 1, too close in size in Option 5.1 (don't consider the entry door circulation, look at the main dimensions of where furniture is and how you feel the size of space). So that means there is a little more room to work with the Laundry and getting that window visible if you "right size" Bedroom 1.

Also, can that front window change size and/or move? Is the front the south side? What can the Pantry window on the porch contribute to allowing light through to the main house?

I've seen this plan before somewhere - what came of those crowdsourcing ideas?

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
chispa

You don't have extra room for in-swing patio doors. Just do sliders.

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Boss Design Center

Option 5.1 is the one I'd test first: keeping the front window's daylight will matter every day. But only pick it if a real bed, dresser, closet access and door swing still fit in bedrooms 1 and 2; draw furniture to scale rather than judging by square footage. I'd ask whether a narrower laundry layout can recover some room. If its plumbing or vent route changes, have licensed trades verify it before building.

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: advice/suggestions for corner shower
    15 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

You are not forced to keep the shower valve in the spot the previous owner decided. It's pex (in ENT?) which is fairly easy to relocate, especially with a floor below. So keep that opportunity open if it makes for a better layout.

The shower walls are framed to close in, which was an odd choice in combination with being held 6" down from the ceiling.

To decide glass vs solid wall vs pony vs any combination, the entire room layout should be considered. Where the main door nests, whether having glass makes the room feel larger, towel racks, niches, etc. Even whether there should be an angle on the shower.

Other points from the pictures to keep in the back of your mind is the kraft face on the exterior insulation should be removed if you have waterproofing on a shared tile wall. And an unvented attic requires minimum thickness of closed cell insulation to prevent condensation in certain climates and also needs to meet total R value (2x4 ceiling indicates truss with 2x4 top chord, which looks about 4" thick spray foam if fully thick).


1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting

Stand inside and figure out where you would want the water to go and then that becomes the solid wall. It looks like quite a small shower so water direction is important. Then decide where the glass walls can go. I clean my shwer with a squeegee every shower and then once a week a really good clean seems to work well so the glass walls to me in small space work well. I do garee if possible square it off.

2 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Linea

Amber, since the controls and plumbing are on the toilet-side wall, I’d keep that wall solid and plan the glass around the remaining openings. Before closing the walls, have the installer verify that the shower pan, drain, waterproofing, and chosen wall finish work together; that is harder to correct after tile or panels are installed. Then mock up the door swing and glass on the floor so you can check entry, splash control, and cleaning access. What are the shower dimensions, and is the pan and drain already installed?

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Gutted Kitchen Help!
    18 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
48 Hour Kitchens Inc

Worked on previous posts gave more room in the kitchen and adding the pantries basically doubles the storage capacity. I rip everything down to the bar studs in most cases depending on the size of the home renovation. If you are able to take some time take up front will save problems.





Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

I there anything I can do to make the partition look less awkward?

Yes, remove the wall. The only electrical that would cause pause would be a multi-story building with units above you, or the main electrical panel at that wall.

2 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: roof modification
    12 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting

Changing roof structure is not a simple job so get it priced . BTW lived in snow country in Canada for 18 yrs in a MCM home built in 1956 with what really is considered a flat roof . In all that time one winter where we had to shovel the roof . If all the rest of the home is perfect then maybe worth a roof change but price out just joining the two without the deck or skylight both of which to me are bigger issues than a flat roof BTW

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

@Steven Mock a hip roof can be low slope, and a steeper pitched roof still has ice dam worries, so see if you can have AI learn that.

1 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: LED Mirror and additional lighting
    5 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

@wdccruise Boss means the other version of lighting - frontlit through the glass. Here's an example with both front and backlit:




Lindsay, just to clarify, a frontlit LED mirror adds task lighting for facework, but alone are not usually adequate for a vanity. There are 3 other types of lighting to choose:

  1. ceiling mounted/recessed - good for vanity counter/sink task lighting and general ambient for the space
  2. wall mounted (located above the mirror) - good for vanity counter/sink task lighting and general ambient for the space
  3. wall mounted ("sconce" located at face height) - good for facework and decorative lighting. Because a mirror is always centered over a sink, these are not optimal for sink task lighting. Combining with LED frontlit mirror could be redundant.


1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Boss Design Center

yeah i'd still add sconces. most led mirrors are fine for makeup but can look flat and cast shadows under the chin, so side lights at about eye level (roughly 60 to 66 inches) even things out. for wiring, put the sconces on the wall switch and the mirror on its own touch control or separate switch. have your electrician plan the circuits and boxes before drywall goes up, that's easy now and annoying later.

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Ambitious whole home renovation - floor plan feedback??
    22 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

I do like some things about the architect's proposed version. To improve on that, so many questions arise when trying to picture opportunities, and reconcile those with trying to interpret what it is you are exactly shooting for. And lack of pictures.

The biggest obstacles appear to be "fairly dark" and the monstrously huge screened rooms and deck in your way of the pool. Not sure what "kitchen feels tight" means, as it is proportionately sized for the rest of house, and the space is larger than what the island restricts because the space is visually extended to the stair.

Assume the Family Room is on the north with only east/west sun? How and when are the screened rooms used vs deck, and is reducing their sizes an option? Is direct visual access to the pool from inside because of kids, or is the pool an amazing looking oasis? Do glass guardrails solve everything? You're contemplating a back addition because you'd like access (visual and foot) be better to the pool other than in summer/shoulder seasons, but is the pool used outside of those seasons, and does it look good in winter that you need that visual and foot access other than from the screened rooms and deck? You have a desire for a direct connection from Kitchen down to pool, but the deck stairs are too far, so you want that connection to pass through the basement instead?

1 synes godt om Gem     Takket af Greg
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Mark Bischak, Architect

"I'd love feedback from folks on the overall floorplan layouts proposed here."

After having time to read the comments an analyze the drawings posted I would have to say you are well on your way to ANOTHER disconnected renovation, and crowd sourcing is the quickest way to get there. Your friends will not tell you this, but I will because you need to hear it and know it. It is fun to play around with layouts and discuss it with others, but your life and home is too important to to be left to ignorant advice.

Convey your concerns to your architect and work it out with them. If you feel you can not work it out with them, get another local competent architect to work with.

2 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Linea

Greg, the earlier plan helps explain why you’re reconsidering the layout. Before refining individual rooms, I’d ask your architect to compare both schemes against the same priorities: the views from where you actually sit, the everyday route from garage to kitchen, access to the pool, and a bedroom and laundry arrangement that work for your family. Then compare those gains with the cost and disruption of the proposed stairs and addition. Which two outcomes matter most to you: the views, easier pool access, a pantry, or a better upstairs layout?

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Water dripping off roof every morning - is this normal?
    7 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

@Georgiy Kharchenko

What a useless AI response, no help now or later\.

"it is condensation and not a leak" - hmmm, I didn't see a sink or shower on the roof for a leak.

"gutter downspout clog" - you can just look at the pictures and see no gutters.

4 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

Obviously cool moisture laden air is hitting a warmer roof assembly. There are lots of variables here, like, whether the insulation is open cell or closed cell, whether it was installed without air spaces against the sheathing via picture framing, whether there is a code-required vapor port if the open cell is air permeable, whether R value was achieved, what is the type of roof underlayment used, whether it is a cathedral or attic.

Seeing the high amount of condensation, and as I write this Lubbock is at 85% humidity (typically dry and arid), it appears that vapor drive is pushing a lot of moisture into your assembly, providing lots of "fuel." If your assembly/attic was vented, then that airflow would mitigate that moisture. But since it is unvented, it is either/both too warm with no where for the vapor to escape.

Here is a paper on unvented asphalt roofs and the underlayment - here

Here is a paper on vapor diffusion ports, it's actually for a slideshow presentation but I linked this because it shows examples of condensation on roofs - here. BuildingScience(dot)com is the industry bible on condensation and code actually changed following their work if you want to research further on moisture and condensation.

2 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
vgkg Z-7 Va

Personally, I'd install some roof gutters and downspout if possible. Your cement entranceway may start to get slippery from a thin layer of algae growth over time. The consistent moisture may also invite a termite infestation around the foundation.

1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
Kerri P

Thank you all for the comments and giving us things to look for in order to determine if we have an issue or if it’s normal condensation due to weather changes. We recently installed gutters in the back of the house due to a specific drainage issue but the gutter installer didn’t think we really needed any installed in the front for several reasons which included there isn’t a really good way to install them due to the wood eaves (correct term?) in the front and the fact that we really don’t get a whole lot of rain here in Lubbock. A lot of the homes in our neighborhood don’t have any gutters. We’re going to get up in the attic soon to look for moisture and any discoloration in the spray foam. Very much appreciate everyone who took the time to weigh in on my question.

1 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Seeking input on exterior materials for new build.
1 synes godt om    21 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

The OP didn't state or show a site plan to understand the distance to the property line. 6' between adjacent 2-story houses is very different than 20' between different height massings. There aren't even side elevations shown that are up for discussion. There is no basis of evaluation for cost or what all the proposed materials are.

So you can preach in generalities and lofty design goals, but that's not the reality for a single homeowner in the builder's system of how a typical house is built, and each project should be evaluated on their own merit, when you have the information to evaluate.

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
Becky Denison

Appreciate the input, all. We do not yet have 3d or side elevation renderings. Very early in the process. Classic long narrow lake lot, so sides will most certainly be straight and boring.

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC

I'll answer your question again:

"Do the entire house in one type of siding, and choose the one that fits your budget. The rendering looks very busy to me with all the different materials."

1 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Floorplan - is it better enough?
    7 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

So, a couple comments on your response:

  • Plumbing and electrical is not necessarily hard to move. Especially a kitchen only has a 1 1/2" waste line, and any remodel in a historic house would need new electrical to bring up to NEC standards anyway. Same with bearing walls, they can be opened up judiciously. Think about it, the previous owner moved plumbing and opened up bearing walls - they just didn't have the vision to make going through that trouble maximize an optimal design. This is why I mentioned "sunk cost fallacy" for your remodel - you can clearly see the proposed is only a half-baked change from current, but is going through the same amount of trouble as a complete concept change would. You are proposing to move the Powder Room to begin with, but it's location currently is bad, and in the proposed is not that good either for the trouble.
  • Usually the best sun light is not given to a Dining Room, because you're not in that function as long, and having the best sun and views while eating are behind prioritizing sun/views for relaxation/recreation functions like the Living Room.
  • Capitalizing on the opportunity to move the Living Room is to allow the most used room to be the largest and closest to outdoor living, which is what most people want who choose to "invest" in their house. This is a conceptual drawing, I don't know the ins-n-outs of your house from a rudimentary diagram given - but vision is what this project could benefit from.
Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
Theresa Peterson

Random thoughts:

- I get wanting to move the breakfast table. One of my layout pet peeves is walking past one table to reach another table. However, I strongly dislike the proposed island + 3 seats. The island sticks out past the kitchen, which makes zero sense, And the 3 seats are within reach of the table.

What I'd do instead: Go with a G-shaped kitchen and place the barstools on the outer portion. This puts more space between the kitchen and the table /provides a better balance.

- No to the small prep sink. It's in an odd place and will not be helpful. Instead, move the main sink to that area; making it central will remove the need for a prep sink -- and it robs you of much-needed storage. Honestly, in a kitchen this size, you don't need it -- even if you keep the sink where it is.

- I'd like to see the dining room moved to the front office space -- a bay window is so nice in a dining room. This places your office /craft space in the smaller room.

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: I am working on house plans & would love advice on improvements
    4 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

No context is given about the project, so any review is limited and with assumptions. It is a very "organized" plan, and seems developed enough that there should be elevations and roof plan developed simultaneously a few schemes ago. 4000sf and the level of amenities with 3 bedrooms seems counterintuitive, especially when Bed3 is small and under a 1/2 story. The outdoor Dining and Seating seemed tacked on, out of scale, and in the wrong spots. The left exterior wall is a pretty dreary facade.

Gem     Takket af vhusted
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
bpath

Who is the design for? family? no kids, it appears.

Arre those basement stairs passing through a wall, at the garage?

Gem     Takket af vhusted
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Platinum Realty

Nice work getting this far — it's a thoughtful plan, and I agree with the others about the laundry. Coming in from the garage with an armful of groceries, you'd really want a straight shot to the kitchen and a mudroom that actually catches the daily clutter, rather than a long walk through the house.

One thing I'd look at from a resale standpoint: at close to 4,000 square feet, most buyers are going to expect a fourth bedroom or a true flex room they can use as one, especially with Bed 3 being on the smaller side. You've got a lot of formal and informal eating space — dining room, breakfast area, kitchen island, plus outdoor dining — so I'd see if one of those eating areas could be simplified to free up space for that extra bedroom or a bigger, more usable family room.

Also, walk the plan as if you lived there for a week: where do guests' bags go, where does the dog get cleaned up, where do you put a vacuum? If those everyday spots feel awkward on paper, they'll feel ten times worse once you're moved in. Good luck with it — you're asking the right questions before you build, which is exactly when changes are cheap.

Gem     Takket af vhusted
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Exterior Design for a Corner Lot
    13 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

Assume an existing house in the last pic with the foamcore model.

You've given your house a new hat. That hat could be removed and put on any house. There is no relationship to the main floor. I also count 6 or 9 different materials in the AI pic, too many.

1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Boss Design Center

Topla Hisa, this iteration feels more resolved. The low retaining wall and planting can give you privacy without making the street edge feel like another facade. Keep the fence and roof/window frames in one dark tone, and reserve wood for the recess; that contrast keeps the palette focused. Leave clear sight lines at the driveway and corner, and verify local fence/retaining-wall height and drainage requirements before finalizing.

Gem     Takket af Topla Hisa
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Topla Hisa

Thanks for all your advice, and now I can see the secondary warts that I need to work on but I feel the base is at a good starting point. Alongside those points you highlighted, I'm noticing things like the thermowood screen board spacing and size all make a notable difference on the big picture...lots still do.

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Kitchen layout feedback please?
    12 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

Usually when you rearrange adjacencies in a plan, it is to take advantage of spaces, flow, and/or make a historic house meet today's lifestyles (direct and visual connections to Living/Kitchen as congregation space/outdoors, daily entry more integrated). I really don't see a strong concept here that exploits those points, and the Mudroom is extremely inefficient and wasteful. The oven idea is nice, but probably involves a complete rework of the fireplace anyway, and is not really presented as an anchor in this scheme worthy of that idea.

I would start fresh by first understanding what is the full range of opportunities the house can give. A better representation of the stairs are important, I'm guessing there is a 1/2 flight up from the driveway into the house that you are eliminating, but typically those stairs are shared with the basement (enter grade level door, go up to kitchen, or the other way to basement). The middle stair to 2nd floor should also be represented accurately to understand how much of that space can be captured or manipulated. The current rear yard and outdoor living also shown to understand opportunities inside.

And, you'd be surprised about how sometimes one little tweak, like say opening up a load bearing wall, which scares people initially, can really change the design to something that knocks their socks off and makes the trouble and expense worth it.

2 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
thinkdesignlive

Good advice so far - and that powder room is way too tight and the mudroom seems like a lot of wasted space/table size is too much at 47”…I agree with a plan fresh start.

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
uCad

I built your new plan in 3D at the sizes on the drawing (14'1" x 20'4", island 32 x 96, aisles 43 / 42 / 40, range in the hearth) to check how it walks.


- Aisles: 42" at the range and 43" at the hutches are the usual minimum for one cook, and 40" at the fridge is a little under. It works, but two people won't pass easily on the range side.

- Table: 44" between the table and the island is enough to walk behind someone seated.

- The island as a barrier, in numbers: the fridge is on one side of it and the sink and range on the other. Fridge to sink is about 10 ft of walking around the trash end (the straight line cuts 13-16" into the island). Fridge to range is about 14 ft around either end.

- If the island stays, 84" instead of 96" would help: the fridge-to-sink line then clips it by about 4", and the passage by the pocket doors grows from 43" to 55".


Sizes are read off your drawing, so treat my numbers as close, not exact. Happy to try the shorter island or a different fridge spot if you'd like to see it.



Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: furniture layout
    3 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
m julz

Currently fireplace room is our office study room. With built in desk. I am thinking of putting a door on that room. Maybe a glass framed door. I’d like to put a built in with wetbar somewhere. Not sure if I do that in that den room behind kitchen.

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

Your second floor addition thread brought me here. It is more than furniture layout, the design and placement of the "Den" addition raises some questions.

It appears the existing Kitchen was remodeled in the past to be open to the Living Room, which tracks with what most people like for living and entertaining today. However, the addition changes that. For most typical suburban U.S. houses, which yours appears to be, the most utilitized congregation areas are focused toward the backyard. So an addition is chosen as a Family Room direct to outdoor living, with the Kitchen and Dining directly part of that. The front Living Room becomes a more formal space (meaning not open to Kitchen) or converted to an Office or with/other uses.

You do have an overly-sized Office, which could have been a previous capture of a garage stall, but it is sized as a Family Room, just in the wrong place for that.

Your addition is apparently to give the kids a play area with big closets to hide things, and because of that is really restricted in it's connection to the main house and outdoor living (small opening, little windows), but they won't be kids forever. Yet you are still trying for the main house to have a connection to outdoors through the Dining, which is restricted because of the location and dedication of the Den addition to the kid's purpose. If this were a typical project keying in on modern lifestyles to the ways most houses have been designed for the last 4 decades, and ROI, the addition should be placed and designed for a main Family Room connected to outdoor living. Then if necessary the existing Living Room or part of the Office would be closed off and dedicated to what you seem to have in mind for the kids.

1 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Renovation ideas
    12 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

Additions should follow right size, right place - part of that is heirarchy, scale, and proportion based on the existing house. Every design needs to be taken in context with all information, and the front elevation here is an important piece:



  • The first scheme is 1/3 the size of the existing 2nd floor addition, and only dedicated to the Master. Proportions of rooms aren't bad, but the placement has the closet benefiting from the front elevation windows which it doesn't need, and the back Laundry placement does not benefit from windows over a more secluded back yard, which isn't a huge need to begin with. The biggest problem is what it does to the front of house, it makes your garage over-emphasized, almost like a snout garage, and detracts from the rest of house.
  • The second scheme makes the 1/3 size addition seem like 1/2 the size because it has extended the footprint beyond the garage (which brings some detailing problems), which now makes that addition very dominant and out of scale on the front elevation. More work would need to be done so the entry isn't overwhelmed and the left side of the house doesn't appear to be a "tack on." Even though the plan is trying to take advantage of where windows are available by moving the Master Bedroom and where the resulting Master Bath would be, it leaves huge closets (that you didn't ask for or apparently need) and a circuitous circulation. Also a technical note but the existing chimney is not how it would be redone, it does affect layout but moreso it shows that the designer may not be an architect.


This is a common 1960-70s house design that I see additions over the garage all the time, albeit usually 2 car garages. Like your schemes have, I do see full additions all the way to the front wall, and the result is as I commented. The other route of successful addition placement on these style of houses is smaller and more "subdued" to work with the existing scale and proportions of the existing house, and also seems to fit your programming. That would be something like this:



I'm not going to generate a front elevation or plan as you have hired help, but if this scheme is developed by a competent designer you will see this has oppportunity for much better scaled, proportioned, and efficient elevations and plan.



1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
oldsue

I think it’s always good for at least one secondary bedroom to have an ensuite bathroom. It’s better for house guests and essential if you ever need to house an au pair or a grandparent. If fairness is a concern, each child can take a smaller bedroom and the ensuite can be a combination home office/guest room or tv room. I like plan no. 2 because you don’t have to walk through the bathroom to reach the clothes closet. That would really matter to me.

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Platinum Realty

Plan 2 for me too — the hall-access laundry and the primary windows on two sides are the big wins, and a private primary toilet just works better day to day. Since you said you don't need more than one walk-in, I'd use that second walk-in space differently: a small homework/study nook or extra linen and storage would get used every day by a 12- and 14-year-old, where a second walk-in mostly wouldn't. I'd also try to balance the kids' rooms rather than giving one a full ensuite suite and the other a much smaller setup — for example, the larger bedroom or better closet for the child without the ensuite. That balance tends to matter more over time, both for living there and if you ever sell, than a second walk-in.

Gem    
3onthetree kan lide en kommentar i en diskussion: Looking for feedback on this plan we've been working on.
    13 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
Clyde Kalvin

You basically took a plan that was bad to begin with from architecturaldesign.com and did not make it any better. Like Mark said…seek professional assistance.


https://www.architecturaldesigns.com/house-plans/rustic-craftsman-plan-with-walkout-basement-4042-sq-ft-25740ge

1 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Help with guest house kitchen
    9 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

"Loves to bake" has nuance that needs defined - a single pie is different than multiple trays of cookies simultaneously. Finding more counter space would be a large change.

It appears, from the large sliders, overly large (to the point of inefficiency for 1 or 2 people) and open Living, and Bedroom being open to Patio and Living, and Bath at the far extremity, that this addition was designed to be flexible, with foremost a recreation room for a pool in mind, that will also house your mother for a while. If so, that would explain a lot of the concept.

1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
simplynatural

Maybe consider ADA clearance requirements for wheelchairs? Not needed now, apparently, but might be someday.

1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Boss Design Center

Designing around the baker is the right instinct. Here's what I'd check on the plan. Look for one uninterrupted run of counter, ideally 48 to 60 inches, rather than several short pieces between the sink and range. If you can, drop part of that run to about 32 or 33 inches. Rolling dough at a lower height is much easier on shoulders. A wall oven at waist height means less bending than a range, but if space only allows a range, give it 15 or more inches of counter on at least one side for hot pans. Add deep drawers for flour and sugar bins, vertical dividers for sheet pans, and a lift or appliance garage for the stand mixer. Since this is mom's long-term home, wide aisles and drawers instead of base cabinet doors will pay off too.

1 synes godt om Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Hot second floor
    13 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Ocala Pro AC Repair

That 8–10 degree difference is frustrating, and it is very common in two-storey homes — not necessarily because the unit itself is faulty. Warm air rises, upstairs rooms gain more heat from the roof, and a single thermostat downstairs often switches the system off before upstairs has caught up.

I run Ocala Pro AC Repair here in Ocala, FL — we see this a lot in Florida heat.

Before spending on a solar roof fan, it helps to check airflow first. A solar attic fan can lower attic temperature a little, but it does not push more cooled air into upstairs rooms, so on its own it rarely closes an 8–10 degree gap. A few safe checks are: make sure the filter is clean and all upstairs supply vents are open and unblocked; note whether upstairs bedrooms have a return vent or only supplies, because closed doors with no return can starve a room of airflow; and check where the thermostat sits — if it is downstairs in a cool hallway, it will not reflect upstairs conditions.

Do not fully close downstairs vents to force air upstairs, as that can raise pressure and strain the system. Small damper adjustments, running the fan on circulate during the hottest part of the day, and ceiling fans can help even temperatures out a bit.

Call a professional if the gap stays large after those checks, if airflow from upstairs vents feels weak, if rooms have no return, or if anyone suggests zoning or duct changes — those need measured airflow and static pressure checks, not guesswork, to avoid making the system work harder than it should.

Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

@klem1 underlying and unstated motive? You didn't know I get paid $192.37 per paragraph?

.

.

Yeah right. Just like most of us here, to help people (for free).

Just pointed out that your statements contradict.

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Looking for feedback
    15 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

Are there elevations or a roof plan? Some things could be a bit odd depending on what was done, like the Living cathedral or the little 3rd stall roof.

Other than that, there are no huge conceptual issues that stand out. There are improvements that could be made, but at least for me, I try to gauge the level and value of design and whether those improvements are worth tackling, as to do a change well it usually requires a lot of change, which may push the design beyond it's position. Things I noticed:

  • Agree the Master Closet/Bath is not the best, but it works. It's just kind of ho hum is the only way I would describe it. The door to me should be aligned to the Linen closet, but depending on width of walk-in that may reduce clothes space.
  • Not quite sure about the closets being used to interupt circulation, view-throughs, or alignment. For instance the Foyer closet with Bed2 closet, considering the basement stair, makes for a visually circuitous entry. Though the Bed closet "blocks" the bedroom hall doorway, those nooks created by the closets make a messy "room" with lots of corners. Also, the Master Linen closet shifts the circulation over. Neither of these areas are bad, just choices, but all 3 closets appear to be appendages rather than integral with the design.
  • The large empty area next to Kitchen, which allows circulation to the Master. The view to the Master and Pantry doors makes those doors very prominent and "exposed."
  • The deck has a nook, where I would place doors. If the BBQ goes there, it's a circuitous walk from kitchen and viewable from windows.
  • The 2car Garage is oversized in width and the Laundry window disproportionate for that nook (elevation would help). It appears you could actually fit a 3 stall and Laundry window all without extending past the outer edge of the main house.
Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
worthy

It's a major consideration in renting or owning in Ontario where it was legalized under Katy Perry's boyfriend.

We considered buying a condo for our daughter in a university town. One walk down a hall was enough to nix that idea. Barking dawgs--you can't prohibit pets--and pot smoke. Wonderful!

Before legalization, one of our rental properties morphed into a grow op. WE found out when the tenants left--having ruined the basement kitchen with flooding, stuffed the drain lines with cuttings.


I was tempted to call the coppers, til an electrician friend advised the consequences: "So, Mr. Worthy, your deal with your tenants didn't work out so well?" Then an inspection by an electrician and registering the property as a former grow op, damaging resale.

...

Now we only worry about equalizers.

1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
RNmomof2 zone 5

Garrett, if you are still around, I totally disagree with Rachiele custom sinks. Leave the sink where it is to have a large island with no interruptions. Great for parties, a large serving service, craft projects, games, etc. Love my large island work surface.

Gem    
3onthetree kommenterede på en diskussion: Does this foam board and wrap installation look right?
    7 kommentarer
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
3onthetree

What a strange thread. Looking at the spy pictures, I can only see O/C fan fold insulation, Tyvek and Block-It, and vinyl siding. Looks exactly like any vinyl siding contractor installation I've ever seen on a century home.

  • The lack of tape and sealant just means that your WRB is merely a water barrier, not an air barrier. The fan fold is really to "prep" the wood clapboards for the vinyl siding, it's not really any help with insulation value at R1 or a good air barrier even when taped.
  • The WRB's use as a water barrier is if it's installed shingle style, which can't tell from the pics taken from down the street.
  • Block-It is nearly the same price now as Tyvek, assume they ran out and Block-It is stocked at Menards. Certainly Tyvek is top dog for WRBs in my humble opinion, but I've personally installed Block-It at times, so it can meet goals whatever those are for a specific project.
  • Tyvek installation does allow temporary fastening with staples, so even if not fully right via the staple method that is all I can say about that. If I had a nickel for every contractor that used staples . . .
  • I would bet money your contract says "install (fan fold) insulation, housewrap, and vinyl siding." No spec, no details, no mention of air barrier, which means no holding feet to the fire.
  • The crawl space door looks to be under a captured-into-the-house porch, so there is probably a lot more wrong than the skirt board touching the ground, these build-outs usually aren't ever permitted.
Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
cat_ky

Can you cancel the contract, and get someone to come in and fix the worst things. It doesnt sound like it will get any better, so best to stop it, and fix what you can.

1 synes godt om Gem    
Tak, fordi du indberettede denne kommentar. Fortryd
PRO
Platinum Realty

I'm sorry you're dealing with this — especially with a young child and a lead abatement program involved, where the stakes are higher than just a sloppy finish. A couple of practical things I'd add to what's already been said: put your concerns to the program and the contractor in writing, with dates and photos, and ask in writing what their process is for a re-inspection or a remedy when the work doesn't match the contract — a verbal “it passed” is hard to rely on later. Don't sign off on anything or let more work cover these areas until that's answered. And keep that paper trail even if you end up hiring someone else to fix the worst of it, because unaddressed lead work and undocumented repairs can become a disclosure and resale issue down the road.

Gem